Information World Review (IWR) Blog Information World Review (IWR) Blog A blog from www.iwr.co.uk

« Business models and sustainability. How do we maintain and develop e-content? | Main | ECM consolidation isn’t done »

Semantic search with Hakia, CognitionSearch and Powerset

The latest GuideWire Report takes a look at personalisation and discovery: the next big thing in our web experiences. We've already seen glimpses of it in things like Stumbleupon, which got itself bought by eBay.

The report goes on to examine the landscape for personalisation in some detail, concluding that hundreds of technologies are vying for attention at the moment. The market needs to shake out and recommendation and discovery will become as natural a part of our web experience as search.

Before tackling the new stuff, the report said "The search game has been commandeered by semantics and natural language, a burgeoning sector that merits its own analysis. The user intent on finding information online will turn to Powerset, Hakia, CognitionSearch, and others to find needles hiding in the Web’s haystack."

Hakia, CognitionSearch and Powerset. Who? The implication is that these are mainstream services to which we turn naturally. But, according to their websites, they are all beta or even pre-beta. Mind you, to call CognitionSearch a beta is a bit of a swizz because Cognition, the company, is well established in search circles. However, these innovations do give us an insight of the sort of thing that's coming down the track.

In terms of Google-like usability right now, Hakia is head and shoulders above the others. It works but it often doesn't seem to exhibit much more understanding of the question than Google does. A search for "What happened to Caxton Software?" delivered a good first result from Cardbox (a product Caxton published in 1982). In Google it was the second result. Hakia just about beat Google on the question "Why did Tony Blair resign?" But it did, rather cleverly, throw in a recommendation to read a 2004 Guardian leader suggesting that Tony Blair, rather than Greg Dyke, should have resigned following the Hutton report. So maybe Hakia does have brains and would be worth keeping an eye on.

Powerset is currently just website words and a YouTube movie, although it has a demo which it will be showing on July 24th in San Francisco if you happen to be passing. The product is scheduled for public testing in September.

CognitionSearch seems to be working its way through specific categories en route to a more general facility. At the moment it lists Case Studies, Government, Health, Political Blogs and Wikis as its active categories. Social Networks is there as a teaser, but greyed out at present. Within each category, it offers document sets although, under Wikis, it offers just one - Wikipedia.

Each of these companies, and many more, are looking for the holy grail of search - a way to deliver relevance without putting too great a burden on the everyday user.

Comments

Post a comment

Bloggers-in-chief

Daniel Griffin, IWR Deputy Editor Daniel Griffin, IWR Deputy Editor
Daniel joined IWR in 2006 after a career as a publisher of guides, supplements and websites for magazine and event companies. His special interest is the evolving publishing and information industry online.

Peter Williams, IWR Editor Peter Williams, IWR Editor
Peter is in his second spell on IWR. Over the last few years he has developed interest in the fields of knowledge management and e-learning, writing and editing extensively on both topics.

Friends of IWR

LI Isues
James Mullan

Lorcan Dempsey’s weblog
Lorcan Dempsey

SocialTech
Josie Fraser

Jennie Law’s blog
Jennie Law

UK Web Focus
Brian Kelly

tfpl blog
James Lappin

e4innovation
Grainne Conole


Recent Comments

Powered by Movable Type
Useful links: About | Privacy policy | Terms & conditions | Top of the page
© Incisive Media Ltd. 2008
Incisive Media Limited, Haymarket House, 28-29 Haymarket, London SW1Y 4RX, is a company registered in the United Kingdom with company registration number 04038503